Skincare ingredients

Retinol vs retinal vs adapalene vs tretinoin: retinoids explained

How retinol, retinal, adapalene and tretinoin compare in strength, what benzoyl peroxide does differently and which retinoid to choose for your skin.

Key takeaways

  • Retinol, retinal, adapalene and tretinoin are all retinoids, vitamin A ingredients that differ mainly in strength and in how many steps skin needs to activate them.
  • Retinol and retinal are cosmetic ingredients for texture, tone and fine lines; adapalene and tretinoin are acne and prescription-strength medicines.
  • Benzoyl peroxide is not a retinoid: it kills acne bacteria, and it is often combined with adapalene.
  • Green Point rates retinal Excellent, retinol Good, adapalene Poor and benzoyl peroxide Bad, reflecting irritation potential and regulation.
  • Avoid all retinoids if you are pregnant or trying to conceive, and move up in strength only when your skin tolerates the current step.
On this page
  1. Retinoids compared: from gentlest to strongest
  2. Retinol vs retinal
  3. Adapalene: the acne retinoid
  4. Tretinoin and other prescription retinoids
  5. Benzoyl peroxide vs retinoids
  6. Why Green Point rates them differently
  7. Which retinoid should you choose?
  8. Frequently asked questions

Retinol, retinal, adapalene and tretinoin are all retinoids, forms of vitamin A that speed up skin cell turnover. The difference is strength. Skin must convert retinol twice and retinal once before they work, so they are gentler. Tretinoin is already the active form, and adapalene is a targeted acne drug. Start gentle and step up only if you need to.

If you have never used one, start with our retinol for beginners guide, which has a week-by-week plan. This guide compares the options so you know what to choose next, or whether you need a doctor.

Retinoids compared: from gentlest to strongest

The more conversion steps, the gentler and slower the retinoid
IngredientWhat it isMain useGreen Point rating
Retinyl palmitateVitamin A ester, three steps from activeVery mild care for sensitive skinGood (Regulated)
RetinolTwo steps from activeTexture, tone, fine linesGood (Regulated)
Hydroxypinacolone retinoate (HPR)An ester of retinoic acidGentle anti-agingExcellent
Retinal (retinaldehyde)One step from activeFaster results than retinol, mild acneExcellent
AdapaleneSynthetic retinoid drugAcne and blackheadsPoor
TretinoinRetinoic acid itselfAcne, sun damage, fine lines (prescription)Not rated (medicine)

Retinol vs retinal

Retinol is the most common cosmetic retinoid. Skin converts it to retinal and then to retinoic acid, so a lot of it is lost on the way and results build up slowly. Retinal, also called retinaldehyde, skips the first step. At the same concentration it generally works faster than retinol, and it has some antibacterial activity that can help with mild breakouts.

Retinal is not automatically more irritating. Many people tolerate a low-strength retinal well, because it's used at lower percentages. If retinol has stopped giving you results after several months, a retinal serum is a sensible next step before a prescription.

Adapalene: the acne retinoid

Adapalene is a synthetic retinoid developed for acne. It unclogs pores, reduces blackheads and calms inflammation. In the US, adapalene 0.1% gel has been sold over the counter since 2016. In most of Europe it is a prescription medicine or a pharmacy product, sometimes combined with benzoyl peroxide in one gel.

It is more stable than retinol in light and next to benzoyl peroxide, and many people find it less irritating than tretinoin. Expect dryness and some flaking in the first weeks, and give it about three months to judge results. Our acne guide explains where it fits among other acne treatments.

Tretinoin and other prescription retinoids

Tretinoin is retinoic acid, the form skin cells respond to. It is the best-studied retinoid for acne, sun damage and fine lines, and also the most likely to cause redness, peeling and stinging. Tazarotene and trifarotene are other prescription retinoids. Because they are medicines, a doctor or dermatologist chooses the strength and how to use it. Green Point doesn't rate prescription drugs like it rates cosmetic ingredients.

Benzoyl peroxide vs retinoids

Benzoyl peroxide is often mentioned alongside retinoids, but it works differently. It releases oxygen that kills the acne bacterium C. acnes and does not lead to bacterial resistance, which is why it is often prescribed with antibiotics. It is sold in 2.5% to 10% washes, gels and creams; 2.5% often works about as well as higher strengths with less irritation.

  • Retinoids prevent clogged pores and are best for blackheads, whiteheads and long-term control.
  • Benzoyl peroxide is best for red, inflamed pimples.
  • Together, adapalene and benzoyl peroxide cover both and are a common first-line combination for acne.

Benzoyl peroxide bleaches towels, pillowcases and clothes, so use white fabrics. It can make tretinoin less effective if applied at the same time, so use them at different times of day unless the products are made to be combined. In 2024 and 2025, tests found benzene in some benzoyl peroxide products, and a few were recalled in the US. Store yours in a cool place and replace it once it's past its date.

Why Green Point rates them differently

Green Point rates the ingredient, not the brand. Retinal, HPR and plant-based bakuchiol are rated Excellent. Retinol and retinyl esters are rated Good and tagged Regulated, because EU rules cap vitamin A in cosmetics and require a warning. Adapalene is rated Poor and benzoyl peroxide Bad, and benzoyl peroxide is also tagged Regulated, reflecting their irritation potential and that they are treated as medicines or restricted ingredients.

These ratings are precautionary and about the ingredient in general. A lower rating doesn't mean an acne treatment your doctor prescribed is wrong for you: for moderate acne, the benefit usually outweighs the irritation. Always check our guide to ingredients you shouldn't mix before combining actives.

Which retinoid should you choose?

  • First retinoid, or sensitive skin: a low-strength retinol, retinyl palmitate or HPR.
  • Retinol has stopped working: a retinal serum.
  • Blackheads and mild acne: adapalene, or retinal if you prefer a cosmetic.
  • Inflamed pimples: benzoyl peroxide, alone or with adapalene.
  • Moderate to severe acne, scarring or deep sun damage: see a dermatologist about prescription options such as tretinoin.

Frequently asked questions

Is retinal better than retinol?

Retinal is one conversion step closer to the active form, so at the same strength it usually works faster. That doesn't make it better for everyone: if retinol gives you good results and no irritation, there's no need to switch. Retinal is a good next step when retinol has plateaued.

Can I use adapalene and retinol together?

There's no benefit in using two retinoids at once, and it increases dryness and irritation. Pick one. If you use adapalene for acne, it already does what retinol would do for texture and pores.

Is tretinoin the same as retinol?

No. Tretinoin is retinoic acid, the active form, and it's a prescription medicine. Retinol is a cosmetic ingredient that skin slowly converts into retinoic acid, so it's much gentler and works more slowly.

Can I use benzoyl peroxide with retinol?

Yes, but start by using them at different times, for example benzoyl peroxide in the morning and retinol at night, because both can dry the skin. Wear sunscreen every day while using either.

Sources

  1. Retinoid or retinol?American Academy of Dermatology
  2. Topical retinoids (vitamin A creams)DermNet
  3. Benzoyl peroxideDermNet
  4. Acne: Diagnosis and treatmentAmerican Academy of Dermatology

This guide is for general information and is not medical advice. If you have a skin, allergy or health concern, talk to a doctor, dermatologist or dietitian. Green Point scores and Skin Scan results are informational and are not a diagnosis.

Know more. Choose better.

Download Green Point for free on iPhone and Android and scan your first product in seconds.

Download Green Point on the App StoreGet Green Point on Google Play