Cosmetic safety

Is phenoxyethanol safe? What it is and why it's in your skincare

What phenoxyethanol does in cosmetics, the EU 1% limit, irritation vs allergy, whether it's safe for babies and why Green Point rates it Poor.

Key takeaways

  • Phenoxyethanol is a preservative that keeps water-based cosmetics free of bacteria, yeast and mold.
  • The EU allows it at up to 1% of the finished product, and the EU's scientific committee concluded that level is safe for adults and children.
  • True allergy to phenoxyethanol is rare, but it can sting or irritate sensitive, broken or eczema-prone skin.
  • Green Point rates phenoxyethanol Poor as a precaution, because of its irritation potential, especially for babies and people with a damaged skin barrier.
  • A "phenoxyethanol-free" product still needs another preservative, and the replacement isn't automatically gentler.
On this page
  1. What is phenoxyethanol?
  2. Why is phenoxyethanol in so many products?
  3. Is phenoxyethanol safe? What regulators say
  4. Side effects: irritation and allergy
  5. How Green Point rates phenoxyethanol
  6. Phenoxyethanol-free: is it better?
  7. Frequently asked questions

Phenoxyethanol is considered safe in cosmetics at up to 1%, the limit set in the EU, where scientific advisers found that level safe for all ages. It is one of the most common preservatives because it works against many microbes and rarely causes allergies. Its main downside is irritation on sensitive or damaged skin, which is why some people avoid it.

What is phenoxyethanol?

Phenoxyethanol is a glycol ether, a clear, oily liquid with a faint rose-like smell. It occurs naturally in small amounts in some plants, such as green tea, but the phenoxyethanol in cosmetics is made in a lab, which keeps it pure and consistent.

On a label it appears simply as phenoxyethanol. You'll usually find it near the end of the ingredient list, because it's used at 1% or less. It often sits next to ethylhexylglycerin, a skin-conditioning ingredient that also boosts how well the preservative works, so less of it is needed.

Why is phenoxyethanol in so many products?

Any product that contains water can grow bacteria, yeast and mold once it's opened. Contaminated cosmetics can cause skin and eye infections, so every water-based cream, serum, cleanser, shampoo, wet wipe and liquid makeup needs a preservative system.

Phenoxyethanol became popular for several reasons:

  • Broad protection. It works against many types of bacteria and, combined with other ingredients, yeast and mold.
  • Stable. It stays effective across a wide range of pH and with most other ingredients.
  • Low allergy rate. Compared with some older preservatives, it rarely causes contact allergy.
  • A paraben alternative. When brands moved away from parabens, many switched to phenoxyethanol, which is why it now appears on so many "paraben-free" labels.

For a comparison of the main preservatives and the ones that cause most allergies, read our guide to preservatives in cosmetics.

Is phenoxyethanol safe? What regulators say

How phenoxyethanol is regulated in cosmetics
RegionRule
European UnionAllowed as a preservative at up to 1% in the finished product
EU scientific committee (SCCS)Concluded in 2016 that 1% is safe for all consumers, including children of all ages
United StatesNo specific FDA limit; the industry's Cosmetic Ingredient Review panel considers it safe at up to 1%
JapanAllowed at up to 1%

The 2016 EU review was triggered partly by concerns raised in France about products for babies. France's medicines agency advised caution with leave-on products used on the nappy area of young children, where skin is thin and often irritated. The EU's scientific committee looked at the evidence and kept the 1% limit for everyone.

Problems linked to phenoxyethanol have mostly involved swallowing it, not using it on skin. In 2008 the FDA warned parents not to use a nipple cream containing phenoxyethanol because babies could swallow it, which may cause vomiting, diarrhea and, rarely, effects on the nervous system. That's a different situation from a moisturizer applied to the face.

Side effects: irritation and allergy

The most common problem with phenoxyethanol is irritation, not allergy. It can sting, burn or cause redness, mostly in people with:

  • Very sensitive or reactive skin
  • Eczema or a damaged skin barrier
  • Broken skin, such as after over-exfoliating or around a healing breakout
  • Delicate areas such as the eyes and the nappy area of babies

True contact allergy to phenoxyethanol is rare. Studies of people patch tested at dermatology clinics find positive reactions in only a small fraction of a percent, far lower than for fragrance or for methylisothiazolinone. If a product stings, the cause could be phenoxyethanol, but also fragrance, alcohol or an exfoliating acid in the same formula. Our sensitive skin guide explains how to patch test and narrow down a trigger.

How Green Point rates phenoxyethanol

Green Point rates phenoxyethanol Poor and classifies it as Regulated, Alcohol and Preservative. That rating is precautionary. It reflects its potential to cause irritation and contact dermatitis, particularly in infants, people with eczema and anyone with a compromised skin barrier, and the fact that its use is restricted to a maximum concentration.

A Poor rating doesn't mean a product with phenoxyethanol is dangerous. It's one ingredient among many, usually at 1% or less, and it does an important job. The rating is most useful if you have sensitive skin or are choosing products for a baby, when you may prefer formulas that use something else.

Phenoxyethanol-free: is it better?

"Phenoxyethanol-free" tells you what isn't in a product, not what replaced it. Water-based products still need preservation, so brands use alternatives such as:

  • Sodium benzoate and potassium sorbate, common in "natural" products; they work best in acidic formulas.
  • Organic acids such as benzoic, sorbic or dehydroacetic acid.
  • Multifunctional ingredients such as caprylyl glycol, 1,2-hexanediol or ethylhexylglycerin, which help preserve without being classed as preservatives.
  • Parabens, still used and allowed within limits; see our guide are parabens safe?

Each option has its own trade-offs. Some alternatives also irritate sensitive skin, and a weaker system can let a product spoil sooner. The more useful question is whether the whole formula suits your skin. Our guide on how to check if cosmetics are safe shows what to look at beyond a single ingredient.

Frequently asked questions

Is phenoxyethanol toxic?

Not at the levels used in cosmetics. The EU allows up to 1% and its scientific committee found that safe for all ages. Reported harm has involved swallowing larger amounts, such as babies ingesting nipple cream. On the skin, the realistic risk is irritation, mostly for sensitive or damaged skin.

Is phenoxyethanol safe for babies?

The EU's scientific committee concluded that 1% is safe for children of all ages. France's medicines agency has still urged caution with leave-on products used on the nappy area of young children. If you want to be cautious, choose products without it for the nappy area and use as few products on your baby as possible.

Is phenoxyethanol safe during pregnancy?

No regulator restricts phenoxyethanol for pregnant people, and permitted levels include safety margins. If you want to simplify your routine while pregnant, our guide to pregnancy-safe skincare explains which ingredients are worth discussing with a doctor.

Is phenoxyethanol natural?

It occurs naturally in small amounts in some plants, such as green tea, but the phenoxyethanol in cosmetics is synthetic. Whether an ingredient is natural or synthetic doesn't decide whether it's safe. What matters is the substance, the amount and how it's used.

Why does phenoxyethanol sting my skin?

Phenoxyethanol can irritate sensitive or broken skin, especially around the eyes. Stinging can also come from fragrance, alcohol or acids in the same product. Pause the product, let your skin recover and patch test before trying it again.

Sources

  1. Phenoxyethanol (Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety opinion)European Commission
  2. Ingredient safety assessmentsCosmetic Ingredient Review

This guide is for general information and is not medical advice. If you have a skin, allergy or health concern, talk to a doctor, dermatologist or dietitian. Green Point scores and Skin Scan results are informational and are not a diagnosis.

Know more. Choose better.

Download Green Point for free on iPhone and Android and scan your first product in seconds.

Download Green Point on the App StoreGet Green Point on Google Play